Dividing Hays County | The Hays Free Press
Joe Bacon for web with HFP

Dividing Hays County

Posted by on Jun 8th, 2011 and filed under Bob Barton, Opinion.


Of Cabbages and Kings
by BOB BARTON

Ten years ago the Hays County Commissioners Court spent much of the summer in battle between its four Republican members over redistricting the 36 bailiwicks from which commissioners are elected.

Once again, hearings on the once-a-decade redistricting chore are under way. Plans are not fully developed yet because many decisions can’t be finalized until the state legislature completes the task of revamping Texas House and Senate districts as well as the soon-to-be 35 Congressional districts.

They won’t be final until the state legislature concludes at the end of June.

Supervised by the Rolando Rios law firm of San Antonio, which also did the 2000 commissioners court redistricting, the current study committee is composed of commissioners Will Conley of Wimberley and Debbie Gonzales-Ingalsbe of San Marcos, joined by city council veteran Sandra Tenorio of Buda and Republican County Chair Kent Wymore, also a Buda resident.

A decade ago, infighting, mostly between County Judge Jim Powers and commissioners Bill Burnett, Russ Molenaar and Ingalsbe on one side and combative commissioner Susie Carter of Precinct 2 on the other, centered on alleged attempts by her fellow Republicans to put together a redistricting map that would force her to move from her home near Uhland if she wanted to continue to serve. She preferred to instead shift several strong central Kyle boxes, which have been traditionally Democratic, to Democrat Ingalsbe’s precinct, thus giving her a better shot at re-election.

This stirred up a rebellion by the majority of the Kyle City Council and then-Mayor James Adkins effectively led a delegation to a hearing in the opposition to the change. Eventually large numbers of citizens off FM 150 East were placed in Ingalsbe’s precinct and Carter succeeded in keeping her home in Precinct 2.

She won another four-year term in 2002, but lost the seat to Democrat Jeff Barton in 2006. Mark Jones of Kyle won the post last November and will serve through 2014.

This year’s commissioners court realignment must be in place by the beginning of the year and will be in effect until 2020.

Action Monday night in the State Senate that establishes three congressional seats in Hays County may speed up enactment of the redistricting of our four commissioners’ precincts. It will make the job more complicated, since dividing our county into three congressional districts complicates all sorts of things.

Affirmation of the these within the county will certainly zip through the Texas House and be signed by Governor Perry. Unless the Federal Election folks intervene, as they did five or six years ago, no other Texas county with a population less than a million is split this much to suit the desires of the powerful political class.

The new decision puts all of us who live east of Stagecoach Road and FM 1626 in the Buda-Kyle area and San Marcans who live in Debbie Ingalsbe’s precinct, into a new Congressional District 35. It reaches into heavily Hispanic areas of San Antonio and will attract one or more promising politicos from that area. It also includes parts of Guadalupe, Caldwell and Comal counties, generally Democratic strongholds.

Next spring’s Democratic primary will almost surely bring on a gigantic battle. The gerrymandering in Austin will force Congressman Lloyd Doggett to move into the new district. Even running against a popular San Antonian, he will probably be a slight favorite to hold onto a seat, albeit a new one.

Because of District 35’s heavy Democratic base, the next congressman will be decided in the Democratic primary.

Not so coincidentally, the battle for District 21 in the middle of Hays (including a big part of Buda), Comal and Bexar counties will be in the Republican primary in which incumbent Congressman Lamar Smith will easily win.

And, lest we forget, Wimberley and Dripping Springs voters will help, not very materially, choose the congressman from District 25 that stretches westward through countless counties all the way to the Fort Worth suburbs.

Ain’t democracy with a little “d” great? Our betters in Austin let us apply the window dressing to their selfish machinations that surely feather someone’s nest!

Related stories:

  • Barbara

    Last line of second paragraph should say “soon-to-be 36 Congressional districts.”

  • Weekly Reader

    “…no other Texas county with a population less than a million is split this much”

    Collin, Hidalgo, and Guadalupe counties are also less than one million in population and split three ways in the latest Senate redistricting plan.

    Whether Democrat or Republican, legislators can’t seem to resist using the power of redistricting to manipulate district lines to the extremes in order to effect a certain political outcome.

    But within reason, I don’t think redistricting should purposefully target a sitting legislator or commissioner, as seemed to be happening last time around in Hays county with Susie Carter’s precinct #2.

  • Lila knight

    Just a reminder about that re-districting attempt, Ms. Carter was targeted by her own Republican Party which controlled Commissioners Court with a 4-1 vote, just as they do today.

  • Weekly Reader

    Or more precisely, Ms. Carter was targeted by A PORTION of her own Republican party, including those Bob Barton specifically mentioned. Others in the party defended her.

    Restating my position, if it is relatively easy to avoid targeting a sitting commissioner, it should be avoided. Don’t use the power of redistricting to manipulate someone’s defeat.

  • Lila Knight

    Re-districting should not be about “saving” any politicians seat – or trying to get rid of one either. It should be what makes sense based on changes in the populations. That’s the whole reason re-districting takes place every 10 years after the census is taken. Unfortunately, that is generally not the way it works – because it is placed in the hands of politicians. sigh.

  • Weekly Reader

    But the problem is that even within the realm of “what makes sense based on changes in the population”, there are scores of different approaches one could take in redrawing the lines. For example, some might think the time has come to combine Dripping Springs and Wimberley into one precinct. It could be drawn that way but there are many other ways as well. What you might think of as reasonable may be unreasonable to someone else

    So with a lot of different reasonable approaches available, I think it makes sense to avoid targeting a current officeholder. Let the voters decide.

  • Lila Knight

    We don’t get to vote on the map – and yes, the time has come to combine Wimberley and Dripping Springs. They don’t have enough population to warrant being represented by 2 separate commissioners.

    Why should another city be split into two or three pieces to allow these two communities to keep their own separate representatives?

    If a small sliver of Kyle or Buda was sliced away to give Wimberley or Dripping Springs the population numbers they needed, would that be fair?

    Would a commissioner based in Dripping Springs (or Wimberley) truly care about a small population of voters located on the other side of the county? Do these regions even have the same concerns?

    I’m open to listening. I just don’t understand how anyone can justify it when they don’t have the population. Are we trying to be fair to one politician? Or are we trying to be fair to the people? Which matters most?

  • Barbara

    Precinct lines are drawn based on population — not on area. The Kyle/Buda area is small in area when compared to the large areas of Precincts 3 and 4
    (Wimberley and Dripping Springs), but the populations are equivalent (or
    will be after new precinct lines are determined). The idea is to have each county commissioner representing the same number of people — whether
    s/he represents a large or small area (amount of territory).

  • Barbara

    If you’re talking about Congressional districts, Wimberley and Dripping Springs DON’T each have a representative in Congress. Both those cities are in
    Congressional District 25.

  • Lila knight

    I was talking about co commissioners precincts – but now that you mention it, Woodcreek and Wimberley will each have a separate Congressman under the new maps. LOL

  • http://www.facebook.com/Meninblack3.movie Thad Conkling

    Will rockzzzz yeah man

  • Barbara

    Lila says, “…Woodcreek and Wimberley will each have a separate Congressman under the new maps.”

    Not so. Both Wimberley and Woodcreek will be represented by whoever the new Congressman from U.S. House District 25 is (almost certainly a
    Republican).

  • Lila Knight

    I don’t think so. Take another look at that map. Woodcreek is just on the other line and in the next district.

    Woodcreek is in District 25.
    Wimberley is in Distict 21.
    Kyle is in District 35.

    But hey – they could have made some revisions to the map that actually made sense. LOL What are the odds of that happening ?????

  • Barbara

    Lila, there WAS a map such as you describe — with Wimberley and Woodcreek being in separate Congressional districts –, but that is not the final map
    (Plan C185). C185 has about half of Hays County (the western half) in
    District 25. District 25 contains Dripping Springs, Woodcreek, and Wimberley.

  • Lila knight

    Good to hear it

Advertisement

Recent Comments

Latest Headlines

  • Yes to bonds The Hays Free Press is devoted to the idea that information makes for good communities.
  • Welcome to West Author Tom Wolfe once said, “You can’t go home again.” That’s because going back to your

The Hays Free Press on Facebook

Photo Gallery

120x600 ad code [Inner pages]
Log in

Our weather forecast is from Wordpress Weather

| Congratulations, you read all the way to the bottom.