HCISD STEM is ill conceived | The Hays Free Press

HCISD STEM is ill conceived

Posted by on Aug 3rd, 2011 and filed under Letters to the Editor.


STEM – Science, Technology, Engineering and Math – is a new initiative, to be layered on top of numerous other initiatives which have not lived up to their billing, to help students in these key areas.  If new initiatives were the key to success, Hays would be in good shape. Let us hope it is hugely successful!   There are 300,000 unfilled jobs because of the lack of qualified applicants.  The superintendent and his wife have staked their Hays CISD careers on it. The circumstances are working against them and here is why.

In an ill advised move, the Superintendent’s wife was hired to head up the initiative. This is problematic. If STEM fails, will the superintendent fire his wife? Of course not!  But, while failure was not an option for Apollo 15, it certainly is an option for Hays CISD.

We’ve got a lot of programs of dubious academic value that survive despite poor performance.

Should we add a costly new experiment during these tough budget times where we’ve cut valuable proven programs such as foreign language in elementary school for “budgetary reasons?” Elm Grove students get by with $1,900 less per student than at Blanco Vista where they get an extra $1 million annually for exclusive “Full Emersion Spanish” instruction. Elm Grove students deserve to have this inequity corrected. Elm Grove’s students will have to compete with students from other districts where there is universal enrichment. With school board complicity, we’ve decided it ok to disadvantage certain student populations. They don’t need to be all they can be, I guess.

The public has a right to know the objectives of this latest answer to education. What are the measurable performance measures the board will use to measure success? Absent measurable pre-determined performance measures, we risk another Academy, where we measure success to fit the latest dismal results after the fact. In this way, they can argue the objectives were achieved – since they set them retroactively after the results were realized.

Despite the poor timing and nepotism, it is worth a chance, provided the board really will hold the superintendent and his wife accountable.

Bryce Bales
Manchaca


Related stories:

  • Daryl Spillmann

    Apollo 13?

  • Will McManus

    Bryce – there just isn’t enough room for me to say all I want so I will be succinct. My son was in 5th grade STEM at CHE so I have some firsthand knowledge of this new program. Its potential is unknown but it deserves a chance before we throw it under the bus due to a perceived leadership conflict. Mrs. Lyon is one of the most passionate educators I have ever met and I believe that she does a phenomenal job in her role. She is not in charge of the teachers that have STEM classes – they report to the campus principal. Maybe that has changed. Her role is curriculum, guiding instruction, and helping the teachers be the best they can be at leading our children forward in STEM – subjects that U.S. kids MUST do better in. I agree that this program should be watched carefully and critically evaluated for success but it needs more than one year for that to happen. I do not think that the budget for STEM adds to the burden of the district taxpayers since these kids would be in a classroom anyway – no net teacher add. Yes, “stuff” is needed but all classrooms need things. Anyway, so much for being succinct but let’s give this a fair chance before we deem it a failure.

    PS – I completely agree with your statement regarding unequal spending between the schools in the district. I wonder what the taxes collected v. money spent analysis would look like per campus?

  • Becky Camp

    Your editorial leaves me a bit confused. What programs are you talking about specifically? Are you speaking of the ones at the two elementary schools or the Project Lead the Way classes at the middle schools and the high schools? The PLTW classes have been going on for quite some time at Lehman and Hays. PLTW is a national curriculum, and in my opinion, it is the best STEM curriculum around.

    Regardless, Hays CISD is lucky to have someone like Dr. Ellen Lyon as part of their team. She has taken on multiple roles as not only the STEM strategist, but plays an integral role in science throughout the district. She does more than you and I will ever know. ( Truly, I don’t know what her job title is.) She is extremely intelligent and raises the bar for teaching across the district–she often times will help out new teachers, sitting in on lessons and even teaching lessons if needed. She has helped to make the science fair actually worthwile.

    Truly, she is more than the Superintendent’s wife. Let’s not forget that she has her Ph.D and has taught at the college level. She knows her stuff, and has a vast background in STEM. I don’t think the district could hire a better candidate for the jobs that she does. (Yes, plural jobs.)

    On another note, let’s applaud Hays CISD for their efforts in making STEM a priority.

  • Donn Brooks

    I never cease to be amazed at the level of hypocrisy of which humanity is capable. In 1996 and 1997 there was enormous criticism within the district regarding perceived conflicts of interest. Now, these same critics are strangely silent. We are now aware that these folks wanted jobs, and when they got them they got quiet, but it is still aggravating to see the level of difference in the way things are handled by the body politic. I wish Dr. Ellen the best and hope the STEM program is a major success. And I hope those critics of those terrible years, who hurt so many people, know that we will never forget and that there will be “no peace in the valley” for them should they decide to reenter the public sphere. And, we wait, ever patiently, to hear just a smidgeon of explanation from the district regarding the many complaints of Mr. Bales.

  • Lila Knight

    There are more of us than you ever imagined Donn. Not so patiently anymore.

  • Donn Brooks

    Memo to Miss Becky Camp: I am a firm believer in graduate education and concur with the premise that Dr. Ellen Lyon adds value to the school district by bringing graduate education at the doctorate level in her toolbox of skills. Let’s hope that the regrettable practice of holding graduate education against teachers in the school district is defunct. We have thankfully ridded ourselves of the worst of the lot who ruined academic progress in the district, but we need to be on guard against seeing a resugrence of this sorriness.

  • Will McManus

    Donn – I must confess that I have no idea what you are talking about in your first post. I am a very involved parent in this district and while not all is perfect (is there such a thing?) it is a pretty decent place to have your kids. I do not agree with all that leadership decides and I am often puzzled by how political education can be but for the most part I am pleased. I don’t always agree with Mr. Bales either but the idea of fiscal sanity at any place whose income is based on my money is certainly something I am on board with. Holding a school district accountable for what they do with our money should be in our job description as taxpayers. It astounds me how many parents don’t care so long as their kid has somewhere to go during the day. Teaching is noble, thankless profession for the most part and we are lucky to have so many good ones around. Mrs. Dr. Lyon included.

  • Donn Brooks

    Mr. Will: Perhaps I was a little cryptic in my first post. In 1996-1997 a power change came into the school district. Essentially, we threw out the baby with the bathwater. I don’t know if there is enough space here to discuss everything that happened, but there was a move on to get rid of senior people and to challenge any initiatives of prior administrations. The replacement initiatives, coupled with inexperienced implementors, resulted in coillosal failure and the school district went on a downward academic spiral. Dr. Lyon is doing a good job and I am one of hjis principal supporters, but HCISD has a tortured past and we need to be on guard to prevent a recurrence.

  • Get a Life

    Considering all the staff who just lost their job and then hire your wife seems a little unfair. I personally feel that it shouldn’t be allowed and it isn’t the fact that Mrs. Lyon doesn’t know her program but isn’t there someone else out there that can do this? Just like at Lehman, we have an AP, his son and now a daughter-in-law that all work at the same school. Nepotism should not be allowed period. It would be one thing if they all worked at different campuses but that isn’t the case and then to have your husband as your boss just shouldn’t be allowed. My daughter was taught by a wonderful 4th grade teacher and then out of nowhere she was accused of cheating on a test(the teacher) she was fired. She had taught too many years was the real issue behind this injustice and to this day I would stand by that woman and fantastic teacher. Our district lost a lot letting her go but no surprise. I do hope this program works but still disagree with who is running it.

  • hays grad

    Wouldn’t it be just as misguided to not hire an excellent candidate for a job because of their relationship to another employee as to hire them because of the same relationship?
    Let’s not just look at jobs as plums for the hiree but duties to our students. Hiring the BEST person is the most important thing.
    BTW—the AP, son and daughter-in-law had been working here long before the “cuts.” And before the two teachers married.
    And–everyone who was cut who chose to interview for other positions was hired.

  • Get a Life

    Hays grad: I wasn’t referring to how long any of the three personnel worked at Lehman. It is about nepotism period. I also believe that Mrs. Lyon is capable of doing this job but as we all know when family members work together it can create issues period. I’m sorry but I’m sure there is someone else out in this world who can do a fantastic job as the STEM educator. It is nothing personal towards Mrs. Lyon at all but it is what it is. As far as the three relatives at Lehman, I stand behind the same attitude.

Advertisement HTML Help>

Recent Comments

Latest Headlines

    None Found

The Hays Free Press on Facebook

Photo Gallery

120x600 ad code [Inner pages]
Log in

Our weather forecast is from WP Wunderground

| Congratulations, you read all the way to the bottom.