Hate crime?: Teacher says racially charged vandalism not isolated incident | The Hays Free Press

Hate crime?: Teacher says racially charged vandalism not isolated incident

Posted by on Jun 1st, 2012 and filed under Hays County, Kyle, Top Stories.


The Hays administration building displays a poster designating the school district as “No Place for Hate,” as deemed by the Anti-Defamation League. The designation has been sullied after a recent vandalism spree that included racial statements directed toward a black teacher. (Photo by Brenda Stewart)

by KIM HILSENBECK

A black teacher who was the victim of a racially charged weekend vandalism spree at Hays High School is criticizing school administrators’ slow response and says it was not an isolated incident.

After teaching science at Hays High for the past four years, Wanda Murphy says she no longer feels comfortable at Hays CISD. She tendered her resignation two months before the May 19 incident, in which two Hays High freshmen are accused of writing the “N-word” and “Welcome to Hell” and drawing a pentagram on her door.

They also changed the room number to 666 and left urine on the door after they slipped out of a dismissal line during Saturday school, similar to detention, school officials said.

The teens, whose names were not released, were detained on campus two days later and were charged with three state jail felonies: burglary of a building, graffiti of a public school and criminal mischief of a public school, the sheriff’s office reported.

Murphy said she was on her way to work the afternoon of the incident when she received a phone call from a colleague who was already on campus, alerting her to the damage. She said she believes school administrators tried to keep the racially charged information quiet.

“They didn’t handle it,” she said. “My principal did not show up until 1:30 the next afternoon, and he didn’t bring law enforcement with him.”

Murphy is one of only a handful of black employees at Hays High and one of 16 black educators districtwide.

In the aftermath of this new incident, she said the Hays CISD administration moved her departure date ahead two weeks, though she said she discovered this when she was denied access to her classroom files and campus email address. Savoy said the teacher told administrators she would not be returning to work the final week of school; she was not asked to leave.

The district did not publicly address the vandalism until the media learned of it from students and other community members.

The students who were detained, according to Murphy, were identified using video surveillance cameras at the school. She said one student is white, the other Hispanic.

They are both students in her class.

The teens, both 14, committed several other acts of vandalism around the school, according to Savoy. The damage included a fire extinguisher being discharged in a science lab in another hallway, graffiti in several hallways that was not racially offensive, and the concession stand at the baseball field being burglarized.

“Inside the concession stand,” Savoy said, “the students are accused of knocking over equipment and destroying most of the food and condiments.”

Hays County District Attorney Sherri Tibbe is said to be considering whether to add hate crime to that list, bumping up the charges to third degree felonies.

In addition to being detained by law enforcement and facing criminal charges, Savoy said each student has also been assigned the maximum penalty allowed under the Hays CISD student discipline code – immediate placement at the disciplinary alternative campus and possible expulsion.

Hays CISD Superintendent Jeremy Lyon said the district will not tolerate this type of offensive behavior. He is conducting a full investigation into the incident and any larger issues that may come to light because of it, according to Savoy.

“We will not tolerate actions or attitudes that are contrary to the safe, inclusive, respectful environment we strive to achieve,” Lyon said.

At the May 21 Board of Trustees meeting, the same day the two 14-year-old high school students were detained for racially charged vandalism, the Anti-Defamation League recognized Hays CISD for all 22 campuses and the district as a whole earning the “No Place for Hate” designation.

“We’re serious about being a ‘No Place for Hate’ district and we’re proud of that distinction,” said Lyon. “It doesn’t mean we won’t have an incident or issues, but it means there is no place for bigotry or hateful and hurtful speech or actions in Hays CISD.”

Related stories:

  • Kathy McCarty

    It’s time to retire the Rebel mascot, for one thing; it encourages racism which is still rampant at Hays; Lyons needs to rethink what he says about being “No place for hate.” 16 black teachers in the whole district? Frankly, what black teacher would want to work in such a backward-appearing high school. The district’s response to this teacher’s situation is absolutely deplorable. Glad I no longer live in the district.

  • HaysMom

    What the students did is deplorable.  I agree that the district did not address the situation until the media forced its hand. (eg. this happened on a Saturday and an official notification from the administration to the parents was not received until the following Friday). I would not be surprised if the district attempted to cover some things up.  With that said, the Rebel flag and mascot have been a long standing tradition with this school, irregardless of how it came about to be.  Just as it is with other schools (Travis High School in AISD).  If this teacher had a problem with the traditions at this school then why would she apply for a position at this school?!  IMO, this specific and rare event is more about the students who participated in the actions and how they were raised versus whether or not HHS promotes racisim.  I do not believe HHS does.  This teacher is well known for speaking poorly about this school and its traditions meaning the flag and mascot and IMO this teacher made it about racial discrimination and continues to attempt to do so.  The rebel flag was flying at HHS  long before she became an employee.  Personally, I have no desire for the Rebel Flag. However, I respect how dear school mascots/traditions can be for some, especially students and alumni.  As far as HHS being a campus which will not tolerate hate….the administration seriously needs to look at how much bullying and adversity ALL students have to endure at that school.     And believe me it is usually kids bullying someone of their own race.  No school is perfect….the students need to be punished adequately for their crimes…and the teacher needs to work at a school where she will feel comfortable without having the need to change decades of long standing traditions. 

  • Balh

    But teacher Sabrina Ray is super fine!!!  smokin hot. 

  • rockytx

    Who cares if it’s been a “long standing tradition”?  It’s offensive and creates division. Holding onto archaic and insensitive traditions do nothing to benefit the school or the community. How about we consider the numerous high schools and universities across the country who abandoned “long standing tradition” for respect and unity when they decided to change their insulting mascots that were insensitive to Native Americans? We’ll always have this type of separation and, at least perceived, racism in our community if your sentiments prevail. “If the teacher had a problem..why did she apply at the school?”–some people, especially those who don’t look like those in power, don’t have the luxury of picking and choosing their employment. All of us should expect some decency and respect…not racial slurs and urine. Boo hoo, she had the courage to speak out against a culture that has a “long standing” history of treating a certain portion of the population like garbage.  It’s disgusting that there are veiled notions in response to this that she “deserved it”.

  • Tired

    There’s much more to this story… and as usual… the HFP makes little effort to get the story straight….only to instigate controversy and sell a poorly developed “news” (if that is what they want to call it) paper.

    Hopefully… most folks who just want the gossip will save their $$$ and wait for the online version.  

  • Gohuggaby

    Seriously,you think it has anything to do with the mascot?

  • Mike Fulton

     Well said Rocky. 

  • nmr

    I 100% agree with you.  There should be no room at a high school or anywhere for a “tradition” that is so offensive.  Not sure why anyone would be proud to waive that flag regardless of tradition, well except for people that identify themselves as being racist like the KKK.  Why would anyone want to share something in common with such a hateful group?

  • Mike Fulton

    If we were picking a mascot for Hays today, would we choose to glorify those who fought against our nation for the right to keep blacks as slaves or would we choose something better? 

    If you grew up eating ham for Easter, would you continue to eat ham every Easter as an adult even if you did not like it?  No, that is a tradition you would be happy to change because you don’t like it. 

    We fight to keep the traditions we like, not those we dislike or those that go against the values we pass on to our kids. 

  • just me

    I maybe just a simply “country girl”, I did not go to hays high school, but I did go to my history class, the KKK, are the ones that made the rebel flag a hate flag not the people that fought in the civil war, they were fighting ageists change, they wanted to be in charge of there on state, and not of one nations. Slaver, is and was a problem for all races and age, all over the world, and it was not the flags that made them do it. It was very selfish and sick people. These boys did what they did on their own, not because of what high school they are going to.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1659828744 Lila Knight

    You are right on Mike! 
    And I’m so tired of this argument that somehow it’s the teacher’s fault… Apparently, she doesn’t have any right to freedom of speech in the matter.

  • Donn Brooks

    The problem with attacking the symbols of the Confederacy is that it gives a hall pass to the inexcusable prejudice in the North.  Illinois had one of the most stringent Black Codes in the nation.  Intemperance toward the community of color was a national problem, but we somehow ignore the excesses north of the Ohio River in favor of castigating the South.  We could learn quite a lot by studying the issue on a wider basis.

  • GG

    This has nothing to do with the mascot.  Those 14 year old vandals did not act based upon some school mascot.  They acted knowing that any action against them would be minor.  That idea stems not only from the HHS administration but most include the entire Hays CISD upper administration which is more concerned with fancy slogans than action.  The academic scores, breakdown in discipline and general lack of supervision stem from a belief that problems can be ignored or “talked about.”  Principals and Asst Principals who hide in their back office until it is time to be Mr./Ms Nice Guy lead to incidents of this type.  Until taxpayers become aware the problems will only get worse.

  • Mike Fulton

     There is no more “North” or “South”

    The fact that other places did bad things does not mean that confederate symbols are less evil, it just means that others are evil too.

  • Mike Fulton

    Believe it or not, the civil war really was about slavery.   The “government infringement” that the confederate states were rebelling against the right to keep slaves. 

  • nicejob

    If you actually knew your history you would understand that while slavery was an issue, the states rights issue was taxation.  The southern states were an agricultural based economy who wanted low to no import/export taxes because their trade was with countries like Britain and France.  The northern economy was industrial based and the industries wanted high tariffs to protect their businesses.  Tariffs came close to causing a split in the country several times prior to 1861.  The new england states threatend to succeed in the 1820′s over taxes.  Of course you don’t learn that in history books/classes because the winning side writes the history in a version that most benefits them.

  • TT

    You’re clueless.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1659828744 Lila Knight

    South Carolina seceded on Dec. 20, 1860. Six other states seceded by Feb. 1, 1861. The Morrill Tariff bill was brought to the Senate floor for a vote on February 20,1861 and passed 25 to 14. If they had not seceded, the 7 states could have defeated the bill.
    Nice job of revisionist history “nicejob.”

    Read some of the original documents of secession. Slavery was the number one concern, particularly after the election of Lincoln on Nov. 6, 1860.

  • ALUMNI98

     I am a 1998 Alumni, and I have to disagree with you!!!…This issue came up while we were in school b/c a teacher decided to come in and try to change it all stating that it was all about racism and slavery and blah blah blah…she came to work at the high school with one purpose in mind…and when she quit she admitted it…. Our football players our student body all stood by each other and proved to this teacher that it had nothing to do with any of the NEGATIVE thoughts that everyone seems to have…Black, White, Hispanic we all stood together all with rebel pride never dies shrits and flags and showed school spirit and pride…Maybe the times have changed but the spirit among the majority of the school is still the same………. There are stupid kids, raised by stupid parents who have ideals that they teach their children…. My daughter is White and has been bullied for the last 2 school years by a black male student…Now should I pull the race card and say anything or just look at the situation as a whole an realize it has nothing to do with the fact the child is black it has to do with the fact that MY child is being bullied and I would feel angry no matter what color skin another child has…….IT’S NOT ALWAYS BLACK AND WHITE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1659828744 Lila Knight

    If it’s all about tradition, why not use the Kyle Panthers or the Buda Bulldogs – the original mascots for the 2 schools before consolidation. What happened to those traditions?

  • Kim

    Hi Tired – give me a call at the paper if you have any information or data that would contribute to this discussion.

  • Kparsons4

    Mike, what yankee history book did you read?  Are you stupid enough to believe that we killed about one million Americans over retaining slavery?
    You need to go back and study what States Rights are all about because you seem to have no concept as yet.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1659828744 Lila Knight

    Less than one million people died in the Civil War. And Mike is correct.
    Really surprised to see anyone use the word “Yankee” in such a negative context. I thought Yankees were a ball club. LOL

  • Williamfriersonfulton

    There are yankees…and there are damn yankees.  And, Lincoln would be surprised to learn today that the War “really was about slavery.”
     
    “My enemies pretend I am now carying on this War for the sole purpose of abolition.  So long as I am President it shall be for the sole purpose of restoring the Union.”  ~A. Lincoln, Pres., USA (19 August 1864)

  • Mike Fulton

     Lincoln was fighting to keep the union together, that is true.  The southern states that seceded were doing so because they did not like that the “non-slaveholding” states were becoming more powerful politically and they wanted to retain the right to keep slaves. 

  • ken P

    Mike you are making a little progress here but you are still exposing your ignorance. Lincoln didn’t give a squat about the slaves, he said so many times. What he did want was the tax money being paid by the Southern states on inported goods.  He and his goons caused the death of approx. one million people to keep that money flowing in.  Was it worth it?

  • Williamfriersonfulton

    The issue of slavery wasn’t the cause of Southern secession nor was it the reason for the War.  Prior to the War there was no attempt by any serious party to abolish slavery.  Indeed, in 1861, the Congress of the U.S. explicitly defended the continuance of the institution.  Four Southern states, Virginia, North Carolina, Arkansas and Tennessee only seceded after Lincoln put out a call for 75,000 volunteers to invade and subjugate their Southern brethern.

  • Davyjean

    Gary Gallagher, distinguished professor of history and prize-winning author, will be speaking Tues. evening, Juneteenth, to the Austin Civil War Round Table.  You should attend; you’d learn a thing or two.  Of course, that might not be convenient!

  • Clifton Palmer McLendon

    RACISM: The assumption that psychocultural traits and capacities are determined by biological race and that races differ decisively from one another which is usually coupled with a belief in the inherent superiority of a particular race and its right to domination over others.[definition taken from Webster’s Third New International Dictionary of the English Language Unabridged (Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc.; 1981)]
     
    Anyone who seeks a racist flag needs to look no farther than the thirteen-stripe United States flag.
     
    Under that flag, many thousands of Africans were transported to slavery in the New World.
    No Confederate-flagged ship ever made a slaving-run.
     
    Under that flag, Ulysses S. Grant issued General Order No. 11, expelling all Jews from parts of Tennessee, Mississippi, and Kentucky.
    The Confederate States of America never practiced anti-Semitism. To the contrary — the Confederate forces included Jewish officers and enlisted men, and from the beginning, the Confederate cabinet included Judah Philip Benjamin, a Jew. (The first Jewish US cabinet member, Oscar Straus, served under Theodore Roosevelt.)
     
    Under that flag, the military services were segregated until after World War II.
    Confederate military units saw many different ethnicities – including thousands of blacks – serving cheek-by-jowl and receiving the same pay and allowances.
     
    Under that flag, Native Americans/Indians were cheated, forcibly removed from their ancestral lands, and massacred wholesale.
    Native Americans/Indians received no such treatment at Confederate hands. To the contrary — Native Americans/Indians played a vital role in the Confederate Army. General Stand Watie, a Cherokee, was the last Confederate general to sign a cease-fire with the US Army.
     
    Under that flag, American citizens in the 1940s were forcibly removed from their homes and herded into concentration camps solely because their ancestors had been born in Japan.
    The Confederate States of America never put anyone into a concentration camp based on his parents’ ethnicity.
     
    That flag is the favored flag of the Ku Kluxers. See http://pointsouth.com/csanet/kkk.htm for pictures.
     
    So – if you seek a racist flag, go for Old Glory.

  • Williamfriersonfulton

    You seem to have a problem with math: “The…bill passed 25 to 14.  If they had not seceded, the 7 states could have defeated the bill.”  Unless I’m missing something another 7 votes against would have resulted in a vote of 25 to 21.

Advertisement HTML Help>

Recent Comments

Latest Headlines

The Hays Free Press on Facebook

Photo Gallery

120x600 ad code [Inner pages]
Log in

Our weather forecast is from WP Wunderground

| Congratulations, you read all the way to the bottom.