Save the Trees: Kyle residents call for ordinance to protect trees | The Hays Free Press
Joe Bacon for web with HFP

Save the Trees: Kyle residents call for ordinance to protect trees

Posted by on Aug 1st, 2012 and filed under Buda, Hays County, Kyle, Top Stories.


Kyle farmer Tim Miller (far right) and other protesters gathered last Sunday in front of Historic Old Kyle City Hall to voice their concerns about the large number of trees being removed for continued development, like a proposed truck stop on Live Oak Spring Pond, that will impact a number of Heritage Oaks. (Photo by Christine Reid)

 

by TIM SAMPSON
Special to the Hays Free Press

As many Kyle residents drove down Center Street on their way home from church last Sunday, an unfamiliar sight greeted them.

Several protestors took to the street last weekend to voice their concern in the ongoing tug-of-war between environmental preservation and the city’s plans for continued development. The activists were once again calling for a citywide ordinance to protect Heritage Oak Trees while bemoaning the city’s latest development proposal, a truck stop near I-35 at the Yarrington Road exit.

“I think people driving by in their cars were surprised to find the city is doing this again,” said Tim Miller, a local organic farmer who has been vocal on the issue of preserving Heritage Oaks – older trees that have a trunk diameter of roughly 28 inches or more.

The proposed truck stop is still in the early planning stages, but the city has already approved Site Fill/Grading Permits for the owners of the land, PGI Investment, LLC, of Cypress, Texas. The plans on file with the city indicate the project will impact a number of Heritage Oaks and the Live Oak Spring Pond.

This is a concern for Miller and others, who have been pushing for several years to pass a city ordinance that would protect Heritage Trees. They also want to see an ordinance that protects trees in the city’s extraterritorial jurisdiction (ETJ), where much of Kyle’s rapid development is taking place. Miller said these large, old trees are important to his community because they provide cooling shade, aesthetic beauty, enhanced air quality and higher property values.

A tree ordinance has already been passed in Buda, where developers are required to provide for the planting of replacement trees when Heritage trees are leveled, but a similar proposal from the Kyle City Council was tabled last month for further inquiry and public testimony. Council members Becky Selbera and Brad Pickett indicated their opposition to the ordinance, telling the Hays Free Press last month that property owners ought to have the right to modify their land as they see fit.

The proposal, as it exists, would create a formal definition for Heritage Trees and provide stricter requirements for developers seeking to remove such trees. But the ordinance is likely to be modified at a special meeting of the Planning and Zoning board.

“I think we’ll likely see a few tweaks here and there before we send it back to the city council,” said City Planner Sophia Nelson.

Nelson said it’s in the city’s best interest to develop an ordinance that protects wildlife without prohibiting city development.

But trees are not the only concern Miller and others have with the new truck stop. He’s concerned about the potential hazard of underground fuel tanks and their possible impact on the Edwards Aquifer.

“Are these things going to leak into the groundwater?” Miller worries.

But Nelson says no plans for fuel storage have been filed with the city yet.

“This project is still in the very early stages of development,” she said, adding that fuel storage is regulated by the Texas Commission of Environmental Quality.

The regional TCEQ office couldn’t provide details on this specific site, but a spokesperson said there are numerous provisions in place to regulate both underground and aboveground storage tanks, including annual registration and inspections.

In the meantime, Miller plans to continue his plight.

Related stories:

  • Lori

    Great  job, Tim! We need to protect our wonderful trees and our precious water.

  • Donn Brooks

    I have admired that spring where the truck stop is going.  Mrs. Laura Belle Wallace (nee Donaldson)  was born in a house at that location that stood until the 1970′s.  Her grandfather was born during the administration of George Washington and she (Mrs. Wallace) remembered him.  Since 1948, through several droughts I have never seen that spring low on water.  So much for that.  It would have made an excellent park and I wish the city would have bought it.  I loved looking at that place, and it is tough to see it go.  Yes, that Laura Belle Wallace was the eponym for Wallace Middle School.  

  • Joseph Vasquez

    Great job, Mr Miller. You have my support.  We really need to protect the beauty of our wonderful trees.  What can be done to help with this effort?

  • vincent

    protecting trees translates in real dollar value short and long term for a community. Even developers can make a buck by having enhanced propery value if preservation isdone properly. But a truck stop? over a spring? and with centennial oaks ? the truck stop has to find a better spot. A site that haswater flowing trough droughts is very precious. Why cant these folks see this ?

  • Lilaknight

    Someone told me that they have already started clearing the land for the proposed truck stop this week. I haven’t had time to go by yet. Does anyone know about this?

  • Guest42

    It’s spelled”s-i-g-h-t”.

  • Lilaknight

    The words “sight” and “site” are homonyms.

    Mr. Dictionary says: site – an area of ground on which a town, building or monument is constructed; a place where a particular event or activity occurs.

  • Veronica Gordon

    Thanks for your comment. It’s been corrected. Good eye!

  • Cindy Lawton

    Unfortunately, yes.  My husband and I ride our bikes to Blanco Vista and up and over the bridge on Yarrington.  The land was cleared (trees downed) 2-3 weeks ago.  There’s a great deal of work left to be done before construction commences but the damage/progress has already begun.

  • Cindy Lawton

    this was in response to Lila’s post . . .

  • Lilaknight

    :(

  • Lilaknight

    I see it now. In the first paragraph. LOL Thought Guest 42 was referring to a word farther down in the paragraph or Mr. Brooks’ comment.

    I bet if Brenda Stewart was still proofreading the paper, she would have caught this before it went to print! Too bad the new editor let her go. Brenda will be missed by many readers.

  • Mike Fulton

    I am very curious how many of the folks who want to protect heritage oaks have put their own money into purchasing the land where they are located.  

    Perhaps you could all pool your resources to purchase more land that you can refuse to develop in order to protect the trees.

  • Lilaknight

    Does that mean you, as a property owner, will be taking over the responsibility of your own sewage and water needs?

    You certainly have the right to disagree with anyone over any issue before the City. But we live in a community of people. And trees affect air quality and even temperature (it’s so much cooler under a big one. LOL). Not to mention aesthetics. An overall beautiful city attracts more economic development.

  • Mike Fulton

     Actually, as a property owner, I do take responsibility for my water and sewage needs.  I take care of my responsibility by paying someone (in this case the City) to provide me with water and remove my sewage. 

    How far I drive my car and how cool I keep my home, those things also have an effect on the air quality and temperature of  the surrounding area.  Do you want the government to tell me where to set my thermostat or whether I can drive to Houston next week too? 

  • Lilaknight

    You generally respond with more thoughtful comments Mike. 

  • JohnA

      L ILA your smoking polutes the air  around you  distroying  the environment  the the trees offer . do you think the city   council should stop  you doing it ?

     There  is a compromise that can be reached on tree removal   some have to be removed for  development to take place, they are usually  replaced by many more as per the city ordinance

     in  my experiance  on the P&Z   I dont think developers  remove trees just for the sake of it .
    Remember a tree was proberly  removed  so your home could  be built 

     I  have many trees and have   no plans at the moment  to remove any of them  the environmental advantage they  offer  is shared by all in my  community 
    many  of my neighbors  dont  have any  .
     as trees are so important to the  community do  you think the city  council demand they  plant some ?

     LILA it all comes down to property rights  yours  end when  mine start and vise  versa

  • JohnA

    ANSWER  again property rights.
     the owners  of the land can built whatever   they choose as long as it follows federal .county laws .and city codes / ordinaces  .

     they  have decided a truck stop is a need in the area ,time  will  tell if they  are right.
      sorry they didnt consult you as to what  to build

  • JohnA

      I agree MIKE   put your money where your mouth  is
     like was expressed in a earlier post some who complain dont even own property .
     

  • Lilaknight

    That’s not exactly what it states in the Comprehensive Master Plan for the City of Kyle. And in fact, part of the zoning they want is for RV, which is not an allowable use under the current land use plan. The master plan would have to be amended to allow RV use. If we amend the plan every time someone wants to do something under their “property rights,” then why bother having a Comp. Plan?

    And if there was a tree preservation ordinance, then they would have to follow the law. Correct?

    Actually, I’m not exactly sure where I stand on this. Although I think trees are a very good thing. And big trees are more beautiful than little ones – and less susceptible to drought. We definitely need a complete overhaul of our existing landscape ordinance as most everyone comes in asking for  a variance. It’s been talked about for a very long time. But nothing has been done about it.

    I do believe in respecting people’s property rights. But the line between mine and someone else’s is rarely black and white. Bottom line is: we have to find ways to get along with one another when we live as a community.

  • Mike Fulton

    No I don’t  =)

  • Mike Fulton

    Careful John, don’t give them too many ideas.  Next they will start demanding that property owners plant more trees to help reduce the temperature in their neighbors yard. 

  • Donn Brooks

    I own a magnificent oak.  Unfortunately, more than forty years ago it was struck by lightening.  It has died a slow death ever since.  It has tried valiantly, but has about lost the fight.  These trees have finite ives, and there is very little that can be done about that.  If I am not allowed to develop a tract due to a live oak tree and it gets struck by lightening I have neither the money from the land sale nor the tree.  Just something about which to think.   

  • JohnA

     Exactly MIKE 
    give them (council )  the power  to restrict your  right to  cut down a tree and soon they will extend  that  power  to tell you to plant one
    give um a inch and they  take a yard *forgive the pun* just like the feds

  • Lilaknight

    I believe that some of the HOAs are already doing exactly that. LOL

    Mike: aren’t you a member of the board of an HOA? What restrictions do you put on property owners? 

  • Mike Fulton

    HOA’s put tons of restrictions on property, and the folks get to read exactly what those rules are before they purchase.  Changing our governing documents (rules) is quite a challenge and cannot be done simply by the elected board – it takes the community to do it.  

    The folks who own land with trees purchased their land without these rules in place and these rules will change the value and use of their investment. 

  • http://www.kylelife.com/ Michael G. Scott

    I agree with Lori, Tim good post. Little trees are nice, but 10 smalls doesn’t make up for one nice big oak!

Advertisement

Recent Comments

Latest Headlines

The Hays Free Press on Facebook

Photo Gallery

120x600 ad code [Inner pages]
Log in

The forecast for 78640 by Wordpress Weather

| Congratulations, you read all the way to the bottom.